I’ve ordered these several times and use them regularly for training and enrichment puzzles. They function as a high-value reward in our routine, especially for a food-motivated dog, without needing large portions.The freeze-dried pieces break apart easily and portion cleanly, which makes them practical for repeated rewards during longer sessions. They fit well into puzzle toys, snuffle mats, and treat balls, and the single-ingredient format keeps things simple when rotating treats.Quality and texture have been consistent across orders, and the packaging keeps them dry between uses.A reliable, repeat-purchase option for training and enrichment.

I have a 10mo old mini schnauzer who is ridiculous when it comes to treats. She is not at all food driven and I spent an obscene amount of money on all kinds of different things that she just turned up her nose at....until now! I bought the 2oz tub, only because it was on sale for almost half off so I thought "what do I have to lose?" Well...This dog absolutely LOVES this treat-EXCLUSIVELY! She is very well trained and is not easily excitable but she hears the container open and starts to wiggle uncontrollably, spinning in circles and systematically preforms every command and trick she knows! Thank you for making such a quality product at such an affordable price. I truly believe that owners would feed their pets quality food if it was affordable and you guys have nailed it! Great job!

This product is AWESOME! I have a boxer puppy who is not food/treat motivated and VERY picky. I have purchased and given away many different types of treats that he had either turned his nose up at or tasted and then spit out. These are crunchy, but easy enough that I am able to either break them with my fingers or cut them. I have seen other reviews that stated that they smell burnt or have made their dog sick. This is not my experience and he has been getting these as a training treat on a daily for about a week now. I use small pieces and sparingly. He is so motivated by these treats that he has begun to walk next to me and will check-in (look up at me) while we are walking in hopes that a treat is coming. As long as things continue on this track, I will continue ordering.

I've been buying Stewart Freeze Dried Beef Liver for my dogs for 20 years. It's been a go-to treat that's healthy and tasty for my pooches. The tubs always had "sourced and made in the USA" emblazoned on the lid and side of the tub, with prominent American Flag. That's what you need to see to know what's what. Many treats have an American Flag, and something like "processed in". If something is sourced, made, processed etc. in the USA, rest assured the company will be screaming it from the highest tower.Sadly, with my most recent giant tub purchase, I noticed new packaging. Nothing new, companies often refresh their packaging. What is missing however is the giant American Flag on the lid, and tub. Now, there's a tiny little flag back by the nutrition panel that says "freeze dried in". Great. One more fantastic product falls by the wayside. This is a pricey product as-is, and there are other companies that are either sourced in the USA, Canada or New Zealand and state as much on the package. Until they decide to become transparent and list where it's sourced, I'll make the assumption it's from China and laced with lead and assorted pesticides.[edit 5/24]I'm revising my review for Stewarts. The past 3 buckets I've purchased are sourced and processed in the good old US of A. I'm going to assume that the issue arose with our supply chain problems, so to be fair, they can't be blamed for that. I wish there was a bit more transparency, but then it's hard to change packaging when you don't know when things will be back to normal. Anyway, I've been buying these for 21 years now, and am happy to report that I will continue to stick with Stewarts![edit 1/25]They've improved even further and are back to what I originally fell in love with years ago. The past 2 buckets I've purchased have been amazing. There's no longer any weird shapes or crumbly pieces at all. They've all been universally the exact size of Dice (maybe a tad smaller), perfectly square and uniform firm texture. This is what I was buying 2003-2015. They obviously listen to feedback, have improved and I respect that. I know in this economy and screwed up supply chain it's not easy. But Stewarts has earned my loyalty after 2 decades and a short rough path. 100% USA. Whole healthy single ingredient protien for your fur baby or hairy adult. Highly recommended.

As a professional search and rescue dog handler, these are the best and healthiest treats ever! Easy to carry and dogs love them No bad stuff just good liver. Try grinding up and sprinkle some on your dog food and see the difference in their eating habits. Been using for 15 years and will keep using Well worth the cost

Really good dog treat, my dog loves them. Different sizes of treat, quite a bit broken and powdered but works well as a food topper. Great training tool!

My dog (a large Doodle) loves these, HOWEVER... THEY ARE NOT CANDY AND TOO MANY CAN DAMAGE YOUR DOGS LIVER. Consult a vet for the proper amount and be sure the top is always secure with "creative scroungers." I don't mean to downplay this good product, but use caution with the amount given. We all want to spoil our dogs, kids especially!

Our 4 dogs luv this stuff...Little pricey but a great treat . would buy it again.. The chopped pieces are not all same size some bigger than others.I give my dogs a piece every nite before bed ..teaching them what the word liver is...hehehe..

I received the Gimborn Beef Liver dog treats through Amazon recently and was looking forwardto using them,because in Australia, all the treats crumble so easily, so this seemed like a great product.I got them in good time, opened them with excitement and nearly fell over with the smellthat evolved from the container once opened. It was revolting.I thought maybe it is just me...so offered my dobermann a treat and she just pulledher head away...The manufacturers of this stuff need to look long and hard at changing the aroma of the product.I know it is preservative and chemical free but maybe they need to get the liver frombeef on a different pasture..;-))It is just not the slightest bit enticing for the dog.So it went straight into the rubbish bin.I couldn't stand the smell in the house any longer.

Excellent product, dog loves it.

Didn't realize how small the size was. Used to get a giant bucket for not much more in price.

I recently acquired a new dog which needed training. Extensive research showed the best way was to use my dog's daily ration of kibble and use that instead of treats to avoid weight gain and keep treats as high value rewards.I saw on Simpawtico dog training (on YouTube) to use some of this product ground up and sprinkled over the training kibble to make it more interesting. It totally worked.My not so food motivated dog, became more motivated. I now use a mini grater to grate some of the beef liver chunks over the training kibble. This is equivalent to a teaspoon of beef liver and the product is very shelf stable. I have so far used it lots and have hardly made a dent into the amount of product.So used correctly, very cost efficient, very stable and a product dogs go mad for. I would highly recommend if you are using via this method.

Lo compre para ayudar a mi petra con la anemia y le encanta...